OSLO B

THE ESTABLISHMENT OF A PALESTINIAN STATE
BY THE GOVERNMENT OF ISRAEL

A Summary of Practical Consequences for the Benefit of the Concerned Citizen and the Responsible Political Leader

by Elyakim Ha'etzni


Table of Contents


"You have a complaint against Oslo? I have a thousand. But we must wait to gather our forces anew, thanks to the Peace Treaty."

- Yasser Arafat

"The main enemy of the Palestinians is the State of Israel and this will remain so. There is no sense to deny it."

- Freih Abu Medien, Palestine Minister of Justice at a Seminar in Gaza

"Insh'allah, El Auda (the return to the cities and villages in pre-1948 Israel) is soon."

- Abu Allah, the main architect of Oslo, speaking in Dahaishe refugee camp on the day of the IDF retreat from Bethlehem.


"... Rescue me, and deliver me out of the hand of strangers, whose mouth speaketh falsehood, and their right hand is a right hand of lying..."

- Psalms, 144, 11

"... And the daughter of Zion is left as a booth in a vineyard, as a lodge in a garden of cucumbers, as a besieged city..."

- Isaiah, 1, 8


PREFACE

Not a Bitter Pill - A Deadly Poison

The Oslo B agreement is being put into effect before our eyes. One tragic picture follows the other: The biblical cities Shechem, Bethlehem, and Hevron are being delivered to the armies of Yasser Arafat. And yet, in spite of the shocking sights, voices are now heard from inside our camp, calling for acceptance of the agreement as a fact - to try to accommodate with it. Some of these attitudes are motivated by political opportunism, but most of them are the fruit of ignorance and lack of understanding. Very few actually bothered to read the small print of the agreement; only a handful comprehend the depth of the abyss which was dug under our feet. Only after penetrating the paragraphs, sub-paragraphs, and the convoluted texts, does it dawn upon the reader that this is not some "lesser evil" or an evil with which one can live.

This is a deadly poison.

To facilitate the perusal of the document, attention is drawn to a number of central provisions, translated into simple English and commentated.

INTRODUCTION


The ISRAELI-PALESTINIAN INTERIM AGREEMENT for the WEST BANK and the GAZA STRIP

(Washington, D.C. - September 28, 1995)


1) A State but for the Name

In the Oslo B Agreement Yassir Arafat is accorded, for the first time, the title "Ra'is", which in Arabic means "President." The structure of the Terrorist Authority Government is as follows:

The result is the full-fledged constitutional structure of a State.

- (Interim Agreement, Chapter I.)

2) The Jordan Valley - An Illusion

The Jordan Valley is to be divided into two parts: The Jiftlik area is handed over immediately to the Terrorist Authority, except for the matter of land. But even this is to be considered at the next stage of retreat which is scheduled to take place in July-August 1996.

If this is added to the loss of the enlarged Jericho area, this means the dismemberment of the Jordan Valley as one unit. With regards to Israel's authority, "the Jordan Valley" as such no longer exists. All government declarations concerning the Final Stage speak of a "Security Zone" only.

- (Interim Agreement, Chapter 5, Article 31, paragraph 14)

3) The End of Israel's Authority over all Arabs in Judea, Samaria, and Gaza

All Arabs in Judea, Samaria, and Gaza, without exception, including those living in the "White" area (C), are from now on subject only to the Terrorist Authority rule. This includes those Arabs who assisted Israel whose numbers, together with their families, amount to tens of thousands.

In area "C", too, armed Arab "policemen" will be allowed to move freely, but "with the approval" of Israel.

(Protocol concerning Redeployment and Security Arrangements,

- (Annex I, Article V, paragraph 6)

4) A Trojan Horse Inside Israel

The Terrorist Authority army in the Gaza Strip is to reach 18,000 "policemen." Thus Oslo B retroactively validates a serious breach of Oslo A which had permitted only 9,000 "policemen." The number actually grew to 20,000.

The total number of "police" in the Terrorist Authority army has now been set at 30,000, including those for Judea and Samaria. However, in light of the Gaza experience, one may confidently expect the number to exceed 50,000. This is in effect a regular army with an infantry force that FAR EXCEEDS THE TOTAL ACTIVE INFANTRY IN THE ISRAEL DEFENSE FORCES.

The Terrorist Authority army is permitted to be equipped with tens of thousands of Kalatchnikov assault rifles, 240 machine guns of 30 and 50 caliber, and 60 armored vehicles. One may safely assume that the Terrorist Authority forces are in the process of arming themselves far beyond these limitations. It reminds one of the supposed limitations placed on the German Army after World War I: 100,000 troops, when in effect the Reichwehr was successfully preparing for World War II.

For decades Israel did not allow the Kingdom of Jordan to permit foreign forces into its own country. Now a Terrorist Authority army is welcomed into the heartland of Eretz Yisrael.

- (Protocol concerning Redeployment and Security Arrangements, Annex I, Article IV)

5) Another Retreat in Gush Katif

In the Katif Block in the Gaza Strip, Israel undertook to refrain from any further building on a stretch of 5 km of beach (out of 13 km belonging to the Gush). In these 5 km (with an option for enlargement), the rights of the Arabs were extended. They are now permitted to build facilities for tourism, fishing, sports, wharves, and a hotel.

- (Protocol, Annex I, Article VI)

6) Israelis may be Stopped by the Terrorist Authority "Police"

- (Protocol concerning Redeployment and Security Arrangements, Annex I, Article XI, paragraph 4 + Appendix III)

7) The Illusion of the Bypass Roads

Adjacent to the bypass roads in Judea and Samaria, Arab building is restricted to within only 50 meters from the center of the road. In the Gaza Strip the distance is 75 meters.

- (Protocol concerning Redeployment and Security Arrangements, Annex I, Article XII)

8) Terrorist Authority Aviation Facilities

- (Protocol concerning Redeployment and Security Arrangements, Annex I, Article XIII)

9) Under Oslo C the IDF will be Locked Up

Six months after the establishment of the Terrorist Authority Council, that is, as early as the summer of 1996, the IDF is to retreat and position its forces only to "specified military locations". This includes the "White" area.

- (Protocol concerning Redeployment and Security Arrangements, Annex I, Article I, paragraph 9)

10) Jerusalem, the Capital of Palestine

- (Protocol concerning Elections, Annex II, Articles IV, VI)

11) The Dowry

Israel will transfer to the Terrorist Authority the following:

- (Protocol concerning Civil Affairs, Annex III, Article III)

12) Dissipation of Illusions Regarding the White Area (C)

- (Protocol, AnnexIII, Concerning Civil Affairs, Article IV; Same Annex, Appendix I, Article 37; Annex I, Protocol concerning Redeployment and Security Arrangements, Article V, paragraph 6)

13) Relinquishing the Treasures of our Past

In other words, the sarcophagi bearing the bones of our forefathers, the Judean shekels from the days of the destruction of the Temple and Bar Kochba, the oil lamps with the Temple Menorah engraved on them; all this will be "returned" to a foreign people.

The use of the term "return" is not fortuitous or due to sloppy drafting. Here, Israel gave in to the Terrorist Authority doctrine (expressly formulated in the "Palestinian Charter"), according to which Jews are not a nation but merely a religion, while the offspring of the ancient Jews and their rightful heirs are the Arabs.

- (Protocol concerning Civil Affairs, Annex III, Appendix I, Article 2)

14) Electric Grid - to International Arbitration: The End

With regards to the electric grid, in which Israel invested hundreds of millions of dollars, the users of which include 150,000 Jews, the parties could not reach an agreement. At the last minute there was a turning point which reads as follows:

"In light of the proposal that was submitted by President Arafat in the last round of negotiations, which was later confirmed by Israeli Foreign Minister Perez [sic.], both sides shall agree on an international arbitration company[sic.] to deal with the transfer of the electrical grid in the West Bank."
The following demands of the Terrorist Authority will be submitted to International arbitration:

The judgment of the foreign arbitrators in favor of the Arab side is a foregone conclusion, based upon the verbal reading of the text, "To deal with the transfer of the electric grid".

In plain talk the give away of the whole grid is no longer contested by Israel. Left for the arbitrators is only to deal with modes of execution. For other reasons too, upon which we need not elaborate, the outcome of the arbitration is beyond doubt. Consider the precedent of Taba.

Moreover, since the entire area, except for Jewish islands, is being handed over to the Terrorist Authority, it would be difficult for an arbitrator to rule in Israel's favor. Being that Oslo B considers the Terrorist Authority entity as almost an independent government, the electrical system will surely be an integral part of its infrastructure.

In essence, Israel has relinquished a complete electric utility system, which she almost totally constructed. Even the supply of this vital commodity to the Jewish settlements and to the IDF will most probably be left to the tender mercies of the Terrorist Authority.

- (Protocol concerning Civil Affairs, Annex III, Appendix I, Article 10)

15) Terrorist Authority Stranglehold on Labor

The mechanism of sending and enabling Arab labor to work in Israel and the Jewish settlements was transferred to the Terrorist Authority. Israel retains the option to either approve or refuse to issue the necessary permits. Thus the Terrorist Authority will have an effective stranglehold on every Arab, through his daily bread.

- (Protocol concerning Civil Affairs, Annex III, Appendix I, Article 11)

16) The Terrorist Authority and the Environment

All powers for the protection of the environment and the utilization of natural resources are vested in the Terrorist Authority, including sewage, solid waste, water resources, pest control, hazardous substance disposal, planning and zoning, noise control, air pollution, public health, mining and quarrying, landscape preservation, and food production.

- (Protocol concerning Civil Affairs, Annex III, Appendix I, Article 12)

17) The Nature Reserves, the National Parks, and the Forests of "Palestine"

All forests, nature reserves, and national parks come under the Terrorist Authority, including control over afforestation.

- (Protocol concerning Civil Affairs, Annex III, Appendix I, Articles 14, 25, 26)

18) The Land of our Ancestors Crumbles under our Feet

- (Interim Agreement, Chapter 2, Article XI; Protocol concerning Civil Affairs, Annex III, Appendix I, Articles 16, 22)

19) The "Right of Return" a Growing Reality

All this in addition to the deliberations (held with Jordanian and Egyptian participation), concerning Arabs who left after 1967. The Arabs estimate that there are over one million in this category, to whose return Israel has already agreed in principle.

Further negotiations are to be held in the framework of the "Final Stage" which will deal with the 1948-49 Arab refugees. It should be noted that almost all members of the Terrorist Authority establishment that returned from Tunis, plus the Terrorist Authority army, are 1948 refugees. All told, this number, together with their families, amounts to an influx already of ten of thousands of additional Arabs.

- (Protocol concerning Civil Affairs, Annex III, Appendix I, Article 28)

20) Hostile Post

The Terrorist Authority will issue postage stamps. The designs, symbols, wording, and subjects are to be "in the spirit of peace". However, one should not be surprised to find on these stamps the portraits of the Mufti, Haj Amin el Husseini and of Az-a-Din el Kassam; the victory of the Intifada, personified by the stone-throwing boy; also sites and treasures of the past, which until now have been attributed to Jews, but from now on (and with Israel's consent), became part of the tradition and history of the "Palestinian People."

Only nine days after Israel's retreat from Ramallah, a letter sent from there bore a stamp issued by the Terrorist Authority with the inscription "Palestine," in flagrant violation of the Oslo agreement.

- (Protocol concerning Civil Affairs, Annex III, Appendix I, Article 29)

21) Whose Roads?

- (Protocol concerning Civil Affairs, Annex III, Appendix I, Articles 30, 38)

22) Israeli Quarries - Out!

- (Protocol concerning Civil Affairs, Annex III, Appendix I, Article 31)

23) In Tel Aviv - Will They Drink "Peace"?

"Israel recognizes the Palestinian water rights in the West Bank". The first "the" in this sentence does not bode well for the future. Israel pledges not to exceed existing water quantity utilization.

Israel is unable, from now on, to license the drilling of, or to drill by herself new wells without the prior approval of a "Joint Water Committee". Such an approval can only be given by "consensus" which means with the consent of the Terrorist Authority.

Similarly, Israel cannot develop any more water resources and systems without prior approval as above. The net result is a total freeze on further exploitation of water by Israel in Judea and Samaria.

Note: The formulation of all the undertakings in matters of water, as in most other subjects, is neutral. On paper, the Terrorist Authority, too, is committed to the same freeze (save only for additional quantities which have been expressly stipulated). But in the Gaza Strip, where the Terrorist Authority pledged themselves to similar limitations, tens of new wells were drilled with catastrophic results.

Also: A short time after the pull back from Jenin, when the ink was barely dry on the Oslo B Agreement, drilling for water already began. Nothing on earth will prevent the depleting of the 340 million cubic meters of water in the "western aquifer" - which means the drying out of Tel Aviv.

There has not been one important provision of the Oslo Agreements which the Terrorist Authority has not breached and to which Israel did not acquiesce. The following are but a few examples:

The strength of the "police" force; prior identification and personal screening of those "policemen"; confiscation of unlicensed weapons; the extradition of criminals, including murderers; incitement and hostile propaganda, even threats of "Jihad"; Jerusalem; the one sided cancellation of the Military Government's legislation in its entirety.

Another typical incident that took place at the first stage (Jenin)of Oslo B implementation: The Terrorist Authority boastfully began to issue civilians permits to carry Kalatchnikov assault rifles in flagrant violation of their commitment to allow civilians to possess only hand guns. Minister Yossi Sarid in an interview with Independent Media Review and Analysis reacted to this news irresponsibly: "That's good to hear." (2/11/95)

A part of the Shechem archeological site has been plowed and planted, and also a road has been paved through it, all this just days after Israel's retreat. This counters the undertaking to prevent damage to archeological sites.

In this situation only the undertakings, restrictions, concessions, and withdrawals on Israel's part are meaningful. The counter-promises that have been written into the Agreements are mere verbiage. It seems as if this were almost by mutual consent. Their real object is a "face saving" for Israel, a sort of camouflage to cover up a one-sided giving, devoid of any serious consideration. The only real quid pro quo by the lights of the Israel Government's logic is ridding themselves of the onerous burden of Judea, Samaria, and Gaza, and in the not too distant future of historical Jerusalem as well. Only thus is it possible to understand the essence and raison d'etre of the Oslo Agreements.

- (Protocol concerning Civil Affairs, Annex III, Appendix I, Article 40 and Schedule 8)

24) Criminal Jurisdiction of the Terrorist Authority

- (Interim Agreement, Chapter I, Article 12,2 (c); Protocol concerning Redeployment and Security Arrangements, Annex I, Article 9; Protocol concerning Legal Matters, Annex IV, Articles 1, 2)

25) Israel's Legal Authorities in the Service of the Terrorist Authority

- (Protocol concerning Legal Matters, Annex IV, Articles 1,2,3,4)

26) They Will Have a Currency

The absence of a Terrorist Authority currency is only temporary: "Both sides will continue to discuss... the possibility of introducing mutually agreed Palestinian currency..."

- (Protocol on Economic Relations, Annex V, Article 4, paragraph 10b)

27) Israelis Pay Taxes to the Terrorist Authority

- (Protocol on Economic Relations - Annex V, Article V(4))

Note: 100% of Income Tax deductions from Israelis, working in areas under Terrorist Authority control, are to remain with the Terrorist Authority. Here there is no reciprocity even on paper.

28) The Ruin of Jewish Agriculture

"There will be free movement of agricultural produce, free of customs and import taxes between the two sides..." The inequality within this "equality" is obvious. The Arab peasant does not pay taxes, is paid low wages, the entire family works in the field, often uses sewage water for irrigation, and uses cheap, forbidden chemicals. The Jewish counterpart cannot stand this competition. The Israeli Labor Movement, which rightly boasts a glorious tradition of reviving Jewish agriculture, now severs the Jewish farmer from the land. Cultivation reverts back to the Arab fellah.

The massive, decisive emigration of Jews from the Land of Israel took place under the Arab conqueror's rule as a result of economic pressure, dispossessing the Jewish peasants from their land. History returns, but this time, the Jews dispossess themselves.

Only until 1998 will there be a gradually diminishing restriction on the marketing of Arab produce. This too is largely illusory, taking into account massive smuggling, against which Israeli authorities do nothing.

- (Protocol on Economic Relations, Annex V, Article VIII)

The agreement provides for "free movement... between the two sides" of industrial goods also. Here reciprocity seems to favor Israel, but a proviso is added: "Subject to each side's legislation." This nebulous language is open to the interpretation of the Terrorist Authority which may elect to restrict the importation of goods from Israel. Not so, as regards agricultural products. Here, no restricting legislation is allowed. Israel's obligation is clear and final.

- (Protocol on Economic Relations, Annex V, Article 9)

29) "Blood on Their Hands"?

The popular Israeli criterion not to release convicted criminals "with blood on their hands" (applied in a racist manner to Jewish blood only) has been violated. According to the Agreement, Arab prisoners will be released in three stages:

Towards the third wave of release, further categories may be "explored". Apparently this will include all murderers.

- (Release of Palestinian Prisoners and Detainees, Annex VII)

30) Amnesty for Terror and Murder Committed Before Oslo

Palestinians from abroad will be able to return to Judea, Samaria, and Gaza without fear of punishment for acts of terrorism, including mass-murder, committed abroad or in this country. They "will not be prosecuted for offenses committed prior to September 13, 1993."

The agreement contains a reciprocal undertaking on the part of the Terrorist Authority, according to which "Palestinians who have maintained contact with Israeli authorities will not be subject to acts of harassment, violence, retribution or prosecution. Appropriate ongoing measures will be taken, in coordination with Israel, in order to insure their protection".

The Oslo A Agreement also had such an obligation. However, Arabs who assisted Israel are being chased like animals, subject to murder, imprisonment, torture and dismissals. Their lives have been turned into a nightmare. Most of those barbaric deeds, including murder, are being committed by the Terrorist Authority itself in the person of the Terrorist Authority Secret Service Chief for Judea and Samaria, Jibril Rajoub.

The Israeli authorities do not interfere. They treat Rajoub as a full, respected partner in safeguarding "public order" and even the well-being of the Jewish settlers. Israel even issued him a VIP card. Here too the principle of reciprocity is on paper only, by the silent consent of both parties.

- (Interim Agreement, Chapter 2, Article 16, paragraph 3)


FINAL REMARKS

For generations to come, universities in the world will demonstrate and teach the Oslo model as a genial prototype, how to erect a state "ex nihilo". From an army to treasury and banking, from a constitution to water and electricity, from land to broadcast frequencies, from education and welfare to satellite telecommunication. Surveying and statistics, a flag and postage stamps, public works, population registry, taxation, agriculture and industry, tourism and public health. From land, mines, and quarries, up to the electromagnetic sphere, to an international area code.

This effort will not remain restricted to the field of lawyers and politicians only. The planting of the lethal explosive charge called "sovereign Palestine" at Israel's side is meant by Oslo to become a national, even international Jewish enterprise. Participating in it will be hordes of officials from all administrative spheres, also Israeli youth in the army and police (uniformed or ununiformed secret agents and detectives) and then economists, surveyors, operators of heavy equipment, experts from all fields, engineers, donors from all over the world, industrial entrepreneurs (in industrial parks to be set up on the borders to supply employment for the citizens of the Terrorist Authority outside of Israel, lest they blow their benefactors into smithereens or knife them to death). All in all, hundreds of thousands of Jewish Israelis will participate in the establishment of the State of Palestine.

This peace has much in common with modern, total warfare that has the entire population mobilized and harnessed to the war effort. By a similar process this "peace" of national suicide will sweep broad masses into the whirlpool.

The outcome is predictable: Regimes that bring historic disasters upon their peoples eventually fall. In their heyday, the masses, blind and brain-washed, support them. Only a few manage not to be swept into the whirlpool. They are the ones who discern at the moment of truth that the merry dance is in fact a danse macabre. There are still those who have the courage to swim against the current of political correctness. It is those that will appear, one by one, on the ruins of the fallen establishment, having paid the full personal price and yet survived. On them the nation will build its future. Their sacrifice and personal example will serve to educate future generations. In the values which guided them, the nation will rediscover its identity.

- Elyakim Ha'Etzni

Do you care?

In the wretched Israel at the end of 1995, "the moment of truth" is now. Every individual must decide whether he is ready to lend his hand, he by himself, personally, to the establishment of the Palestine Arab State in Eretz Yisrael, which by its definition and very nature is meant and programmed to inherit the Jewish State.

Therefore, dear readers, be mustered now and answer the two questions attached herewith.

(PLEASE SEND YOUR ANSWERS TO THE FOLLOWING QUESTIONS TO THE ADDRESS BELOW)

1) Will you take part, in any capacity, private or public, in the implementation of the Oslo Agreement?

Yes/No

2) In your opinion should the opposition declare its refusal to proceed with the implementation of the Oslo Agreements once it attains power?

Yes/No

To:

The Action Committee for the Abolishment of the Autonomy Plan
P.O.B. 3194
Jerusalem 91031
Israel

Telephone: +972 2 810 029
or tel/fax: +972 2 996 1878

The Elyakim Ha'etzni archive: http://www.shef.ac.uk/students/md/md911783/haetzni.html